Differential Diagnosis of Infectious Diseases

Book Review: Differential Diagnosis of Infectious Diseases

Differential Diagnosis of Infectious Diseases (1996) by David Schlossberg MD is one of those rare let-me-try-to-tell-you-in-350-pages-or-less-everything-I’ve-ever-learned-in-a-lifetime-of-clinical-practice types of medical books.
Unlike most microbiology and infectious diseases books, which are organized on the basis of bugs or diseases, Differential Diagnosis is arranged on the basis of specific clinical problems or chief complaints (fever, pneumonitis, diarrhea, rash, arthritis or lymphadenopathy). This is a superior arrangement because it reflects the way in which clinicians approach problems in the real world.
Differential Diagnosis of Infectious Diseases
The book helps the reader tease apart various pathogens on the basis of the patient history and physical examination. Classic associations (tularemia with rabbits, psittacosis with birds, etc.) are all listed in tables, as are the important clinical signs and diagnostic methods for the more bread-and-butter bugs. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the book contains entries which alert the reader about noninfectious diseases that can mimic infectious diseases. For example, the author lists eosinophilic pneumonia and pulmonary embolism as possible mimickers of acute infectious pneumonitis. This reinforces the important concept that every doctor, even a specialist, is a generalist first and needs to be aware of diagnostic possibilities that, technically speaking, could be considered to fall outside to the province of his or her specialty.
As I’ve mentioned elsewhere:

“a well-developed knowledge of clinical microbiology is critical for the practicing physician in any medical field. Bacteria, viruses, and protozoans have no respect for the distinction between ophthalmology, pediatrics, trauma surgery, or geriatric medicine. Microbiology is one of the few courses where much of the ‘minutia’ is regularly used by the practicing physician.”

Mark Gladwin MD, Clinical Microbiology Made Ridiculously Simple (2011), preface

Thus, I recommend Differential Diagnosis of Infectious Diseases very highly to anyone who is interested in any aspect of medicine. In particular, medical students and residents would greatly benefit from this book.
It is one of the best medical books of all time and a ranking book in Infectious Diseases: A Curriculum for Self Guided Learners.

Comments

2 responses to “Book Review: Differential Diagnosis of Infectious Diseases”

  1. Amir Avatar
    Amir

    Hi Dr Yoffe,

    I’m just wondering if you’ve looked at Schlossberg’s more recently published ‘Clinical Infectious Diseases, 2nd ed.’

    Based on your review, I’ve been quite keen to get my hands on a copy, but so far have not been able to find one. I’m guessing his Clinical Infectious Diseases is the successor to Differential Diagnosis though.

    1. Mark Yoffe, MD Avatar

      Hi Amir,

      Clinical Infectious Diseases, 2e (2015) is an enormous 1,500 page textbook, edited (and not written) by Dr. Schlossberg. It is by no means a successor to Differential Diagnosis of Infectious Diseases, 1e (1996), which was authored by Dr. Schlossberg and is only about 260 pages long.

      Differential Diagnosis is a much easier read, and most of the pathology in it hasn’t changed by much, if at all.

      I therefore very much still favor and recommend Differential Diagnosis of Infectious Diseases, 1e (1996).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *